RELIABILITY OF PCB ALTERNATE SURFACE FINISHES IN A HARSH INDUSTRIAL ENVIRONMENTAuthor: Robert Veale
Company: Rockwell Automation
Date Published: 9/25/2005 Conference: SMTA International
The type of corrosion in the industrial environment is typically sulfur-driven corrosion and is found in steel, paper and tire manufacturing as well as other industrial processes. In this study, four alternate PCB finishes were subjected to an accelerated mixed flowing gas corrosion test and the results analyzed. The important findings of this study can be summarized as follows:
1) The immersion gold (ENIG) and immersion silver surface finishes failed early in the testing. These coatings are the most susceptible to corrosion failures and are expected to be much more susceptible than the traditional Sn/Pb HASL coatings. The use of these two coatings may make the PCB the weak link with regard to the robustness of the electronic module to corrosion.
2) The Instrument Society of America (ISA) has classified several levels of environmental severity for process and control systems: G1, G2, G3 and GX. G1 is benign and GX is open-ended and the most severe.  None of the coatings can be considered immune from failure in an ISA G3 environment. The immersion tin and OSP coatings could be expected to survive an ISA G2 environment.
3) The gold and silver coatings could not be expected to survive a mid to high G2 environment based on these test results.
As a side experiment, a tin/silver/copper and Sn/Cu/Ni solder alloys were applied and tested in this corrosive environment. There is no indication that the low silverbearing alloys will lead to corrosion failures due to silver migration. In fact, the solder coatings are protective against corrosion and if offered as a lead-free HASL PCB coating would offer superior corrosion protection.
Key words: PCB, corrosion, sulfur, ENIG, OSP, immersion silver, immersion tin. HASL
Members download articles for free:
Not a member yet?
What else do you get when you join SMTA? Read about all of the benefits that go along with membership.
Notice: Sharing of articles is restricted to just your immediate work group. Downloaded papers should not be stored on an external network or shared on the internet.